Menu

Monday, 15 June 2015

052) The Chief Rabbi's Retraction

While walking through a Modern Orthodox institution recently, I was chatting to a colleague who noticed I was holding a copy of the book; ‘To Heal a Fractured World’, by Chief Rabbi Jonathan Sacks. Being a great admirer of Rabbi Sacks, I was rather taken aback when he asked why I was reading such ‘controversial literature’. Intrigued to find out what was so contentious about the man, I discovered that in 2003, Rabbi Sacks was pressured into retracting and deleting sections of his book; ‘The Dignity of Difference’. Apparently, his own Beth Din said that parts of the book were “inconsistent with basic Jewish beliefs.” And Rabbi Elyashiv said it was “contrary to our faith in the Holy Torah”, and was unfit to be brought into the home.

What did Rabbi Sacks say that brought about such scathing attacks?

In the ‘censored’ version, he wrote; “G-d is universal, religions are particular...G-d has spoken to mankind in many languages: through Judaism to Jews, Christianity to Christians, Islam to Muslims... G-d is greater than religion...He is only partially comprehended by any faith...He exists in my faith, but also in yours.”
The sentence; “No one creed has a monopoly on spiritual truth”, has been deleted.

Some felt that he had gone too far in accepting the ‘validity’ of other religions.
   
I can understand why some felt he had gone too far. There are some major and fundamental differences between Judaism and other faiths. Many of these differences are theologically and philosophically irreconcilable.

However, as an intellectual exercise, and in the interest of freedom of (Torah) expression, take a look at some very different perspectives on other religions, by some of our leading rabbinical thinkers.



The Rambam


THE RAMBAM’S VIEW ON OTHER RELIGIONS:

Rabbi Moshe Maimonides (1135-1204) writes that in general, both Christianity and Islam pave the way for universal acceptance of Mashiach. As a result of the emergence of both these religions; “the world has become full of the ideas of Mashiach, Torah and commandments, which have spread to distant lands and nations.”[1]

Notwithstanding this broad and sweeping statement, the Rambam considers Christianity to be a form of Idolatry. He says this in a number of different places[2], and is quite outspoken in his reference their houses of worship as “pagan houses of worship without any doubt”.
His view on Islam is very different; “The Ishmaelites are not idol worshippers at all and they worship the singular G-d properly and without blemish.”[3] As a consequence of this view, Jews and Muslims have often shared the same houses of worship.

Then, in a surprising and dramatic turn around, the Rambam adds a caveat: When it comes to social and religious interaction with members of both faiths, he says; “It is permitted to teach the commandments to Christians and to attract them to our religion, while one should not do the same with Ishmaelites.” This is because Christians accepted the authority of the Torah and never denied its authenticity. Whereas Muslims, he says, although their books describe the giving of the Torah to the Jews, consider every point of difference between them and Jews to be a either a falsification of, or mistakes in, textual transmission on the part of the Jews, and that they (the Muslims) indeed have the correct tradition.

The Rambam’s view is clear albeit rather paradoxical: Christianity is Idolatry. Islam is Monotheistic. Yet, theologically, Christians may be engaged with in preference to Muslims because of their acceptance of the basic authority of the Torah. Yet overall, both are indispensable in terms of core principles and preparation for Mashiach.

Concerning his oft quoted and oft misunderstood statement that “the pious of the nations have a share in the world to come” -  this is only when they declare their commitment to uphold the seven Noachide laws[4] before a Jewish Beit Din.[5] This, not being a common practice, puts a very different pragmatic spin on the popular perception of this famous statement, and is indicative of the Rambam’s uncompromising stance on the matter.



RASHBA:

The Rashba[6] , holding a similar view to the Rambam, says that Moslems are not idol worshippers, but; “all other gentiles are considered to be idol worshippers”



THE MEIRI:

Rabbi Menachem Ha Meiri (1249-1315)[7], on the other hand has probably the most radically liberal view on Christianity and Islam that is to be found in all of Torah literature.  He posits that the notion of idolatry has absolutely disappeared from society (barring what he refers to as some fringes or ‘extremities’ of civilization). Idolatry, in his view has essentially become extinct, and replaced by more developed religions, with Christianity and Islam both falling under the broad banner of monotheistic religions. He refers to them as ‘umot ha-gedurot be-darcei ha-datot’, or ‘nations restricted by ways of religion’, as opposed to the idolaters of old who thrived on total anarchy.[8]

Jewish law does contain several references to inequality between Jews and non-Jews. For example; If a Jew’s animal damages the property of a Gentile, the Jew is not liable. But if a Gentile’s animal damages the property of a Jew, the Gentile is liable. According to the Meiri, the ‘non-Jews’ in such examples of asymmetry in Jewish law, are specifically the ancient idolaters, who lost their rights to be protected by the very laws they sought to undermine.  He says of the ancient pagans; “All these people possess no religion and submit to the fear of no divinity”. Contemporary Gentiles, however, were to be treated no different from Jews, because their religions gave them a sense of law and order.

He continues; “Discriminatory rules such as this were instituted in times when those Gentiles were devout in their idolatry. But now their idolatry has come to an end in most places, and there is accordingly no need to be stringent with them as in the old regulations.”[9]

In a similar vein, the Meiri offers a remarkable explanation in his commentary to a text in the Gemora; “A Notzri (Christian) may not be traded with”. He says; “This refers (not to Christians but) to the (idolatrous) nation of Nevuchadnetzer , the Babylonian King.”[10]

Commenting on the Gemora in Bava Kama, he says; “All the people who are of the nations that are restricted by the ways of their religion and worship the divinity in any way, even if their faith is far from ours, are excluded from the principle of inequality. Rather, they are like full-fledged Jews with respect to these matters, with no distinction whatsoever.”[11]

Regarding the mitzvah of returning lost property, which only has to be performed to “your brother”[12], and not to Gentiles, the Meiri says; “The reference is to everyone who is ‘restricted by the ways of their religion’.”[13] Accordingly, the Meiri regards contemporary non-Jews to fall under the category of ‘achicha’, your brother, and ‘re’ehu’, your peer.

Again, commenting on Bava Kama, he says; “All those who follow the seven laws of Noah are treated in our courts as we are treated in theirs, and we do not accord ourselves favourable treatment. It goes without saying that the same applies to nations restricted by ways of their religion.”[14] Amazingly, here the Meiri seems to regard contemporary non-Jews as having a higher status than those who merely observe the seven Noachide laws.

As demonstrated, the Meiri differs spectacularly from the view of the Rambam. So much so that some simply couldn't accept his radically tolerant outlook and insisted that he wrote these commentaries specifically for the censors in order to appease the non-Jews. The Chatam Sofer[15], for example, wrote about a Meiri text; “It is a mitzvah to wipe it out, for it did not emerge from his holy mouth.”[16] The implication here is not just that the Meiri wrote to appease non-Jews but that his views on that issue were outright forgeries.

The interesting thing though is that the Chatam Sofer never gave any reasons for his sweeping statement[17]. And he never saw the writings of the Meiri on Bava Kama first hand, because he only quoted them through secondary sources (such as the Shita Mekubetzet in the above example). Also, he couldn't have been familiar with the Meiri on Avodah Zara (where the “nations bound by religion” concept was formulated), because it was only published in 1944, more than 100 years after his passing. Yet, notwithstanding all this, from then on, the views of the Meiri regarding non-Jews lost much of their credibility.[18]


R Moshe Isserless


RAMO:

Rabbi Moshe Isserless[19] explains that in Jewish Law, the Trinity is considered to be “Shituff” or “partnering” G-d with another being. For a Jew, “Shituff” would be absolutely forbidden. The question is whether or not it is forbidden for a non-Jew.  The poskim (halachik authorities) are divided on this issue. As we have seen, the Rambam holds that it is forbidden even to a non-Jew, to the extent that if he practices “Shituff”, he is considered an idolater. The Ramo, however takes a different view. He maintains that partnering G-d with another being is permitted to non-Jews.[20]


The Maharal of Prague

MAHARAL OF PRAGUE:

The Maharal[21], taking a similar tack, writes; “Anyone who accepts upon himself to worship the First Cause, falls into the category of a ‘ger toshav’[22] (a resident stranger), who is not discriminated against by the laws (as in Bava Kama 4,3).”

BE’ER HAGOLAH:

In a similar vein, R Moshe Rivkes[23], commentating on the Shulchan Aruch, says that the discriminatory laws were only directed towards the “idolaters of earlier times, who believed in neither the Exodus from Egypt nor Creation ex nihilo. But concerning contemporary gentiles...since they believe in the Exodus, Creation ex nihilo, and other fundamentals (these laws do not apply), since their intent is to the Creator.”


R Zvi Hirsch Chayes


TIFERET LE'YISRAEL
One of the first rabbinic authorities to actually acknowledge the Meiri as a source text, was R Zvi Hirsch Chayes[24]. Fascinatingly, he is the only commentator in the Vilna Shass to hold a Ph.D. He writes; “Christians, who believe in religion...Torah from Heaven and in the existence of G-d, are absolutely regarded by us as ‘gerim toshavim’, and the seven Noachide laws are built into both Christian and Moslem legal systems.”[25]


TORAH TEMIMAH

About fifty years later, the Torah Temimah[26] writes that the discriminatory laws; “...do not apply to those nations who observe the seven Noachide laws, and these are most of the contemporary nations, which are regarded as Jews in regard to these matters.”[27]


RAMACH:

R Chalfon Moshe HaCohen[28] ruled that; “The bans[29]  only applied to the idolatrous nations of ancient times. But today, when idolatry has ceased to exist in almost all parts of the world, and all the Gentile nations believe in the Creator...we make no distinction with regard to Jew and Gentile in these matters.”

R Avraham Yitzchak HaKohden Kook


CHIEF RABBI AVRAHAM YITZCHAK HAKOHEN KOOK:

The first Askenazi Chief Rabbi of Israel, declared that Moslems and Christians living in a Jewish society, are to be treated as ‘gerim toshavim’, with full civil liberties, just like Jews.[30] He wrote; “The fundamental view is the Meiri’s. Nations bound by descent customs between man and his fellow, should be considered ‘gerim toshavim’.[31]


TANNA DE'VEI ELIYAHU;

According to a 10th Century text from Tanna De'Vei Eliyahu (ch 9); "I call heaven and earth to witness that whether man or woman, whether servant or maidservant, whether Gentile or Jew, the Holy Spirit rests upon a person according to his deed".




CONCLUSION:

It is well known that throughout our history, some sensitive texts had to be emended because it was feared that the original texts would fuel anti-Semitism. However, no absolute certainty exists as to exactly which texts were emended.  We have taken a look at many texts spanning a period of almost a thousand years. Some may have been written for ‘appeasement’.  But by the same token, some must have been the authors genuine interpretations.

If one does accept the authority of even just some of these texts, the questions beg; 
Would our modern day ‘censors’ who confronted Rabbi Sacks, similarly want all these texts to be retracted retroactively?  
Would these views also be branded as “inconsistent with basic Jewish beliefs” and unfit to be brought into the home?

Submitting to the fact that our traditional opinions on other religions do differ significantly and dramatically, surely we must also submit that they all still exist within the broad framework of Torah thinking. One could find many reasons to take umbrage to what Rabbi Sacks wrote. But one could also, surely, make an argument that the Chief Rabbi was drawn to his way of thinking, by much textual precedent.

I can also understand, as Rabbi Norman Bernhard used to say, that; “There is salvation outside of the synagogue.” He told me he chose the term ‘salvation’ deliberately, because of its non-Jewish connotation. Non-Jews have no need for Judaism and can and should perfectly function within their own belief systems. If another religion is relevant to another creed, why can that religion not be valid for THEM? 
In this sense, could one not also understand the context and tenor of the Chief Rabbi’s pre-censored statements - remembering that he was communicating with an international readership, including people of diverse creeds, many of whom respectfully consider him to be a leading thinker of our times? 
He was speaking as a representative of Judaism to the widest of audiences, and was taking full advantage of his honed ability to wax lyrical.

In the final analysis, considering that Rabbi Sacks was speaking Hashkafa (theological philosophy), writing to ‘appease’, to create tolerance in an age of intolerance, and not to formulate or pasken Halacha (religious legalities)  -  was his punishment not perhaps a little disproportionate to his ‘crime’?





[1] Yad Hachazakah.
[2] Hilchot Avoda Zara 9,4.  Commentary to Mishna Avoda Zara 1,3. Avoda Zara 4.
[3] Letter to Obadya the convert.
[4] These seven laws are: The prohibitions of committing murder, idolatry, theft, incest, blasphemy, cruelty to animals, and the injunction to establish civil court of law.
[5] Mishneh Torah, Hilchot Melachim  8:10-11.
[6] R Shlomo ben Avraham Aderet 1235-1310, Torat HaBayit, book 5, chapter 4.
[7] The Me’iri is one of the most monumental commentators on the Talmud. Yet, interestingly, his work was largely unknown until recent times. This is why its influence has been rather minimalised because it was left out of the halachic process. Some authorities, although having great respect for him, will not rely on his teachings because of this.
[8] See “Ones possessed of Religion”, by Dr Moshe Halbertal.
[9] Beit HaBechira, Avodah Zara p 28.
[10] Ibid p 4.                             
[11] Beit HaBechira Bava Kama p 330 (Schlesinger ed.)
[12] Deut. 22,3.
[13] Beit HaBechira, Bava Metzia, p 100 (Schlesinger ed.)
[14] Beit HaBechira, Bava Kama p 122 (Schlesinger ed.)
[15] R Moshe Schreiber 1762-1839.
[16] Kovetz Teshuvot  paragraph 90.
[17] See Kotzk Blog 48) ‘Contemporary Daas Torah’; where (unlike traditional halachic rulings), according to the Daas Torah concept, no explanations are necessary.
[18] Even the the Chatam Sofer Institute which published the Responsa Anthology (1973), while quoting our abovementioned statement, added in a note; “The words of our master ‘It did not emerge from his holy mouth’, are puzzling, for the Meiri explicitly stated this view numerous times in his works.”
[19] 1520-1572
[20] Darchei Moshe 2 on Orach Chayim 156. (However see Nodah BeYehuda, who says the Ramo holds that worshiping ‘beshituff’ is forbidden to a non-Jew.)
[21] R Yehudah Loew, 1520-1609.
[22] An interesting halachik conundrum, however, is created when a gentile is considered to be a ‘ger toshav’- because the prohibition against intermarriage with them would shift from a Torah prohibition, to that of a rabbinic prohibition. This of course would be halachically untenable, (unless the distinction is made that a gentile is a ‘ger toshav’ only with regard to the discriminatory laws, but not with regard to intermarriage, which would remain a Torah prohibition.)
[23] Author of Be’er HaGolah, 1596-1671.
[24] Author of Tiferet LeYisrael, 1805-1855. Rabbi Berel Wein calls him the R Samson Rafael Hirsch of Eastern Europe, and says he was; “simultaneously a talmid chacham and secular scholar. He aimed to fight the haskala with its own weapons, but because of his time and place, he came under suspicion as a maskil himself. The tragic story of this misunderstood genius is the eternal story of the Jewish people, struggling to walk the tightrope between Torah and modernity.”
[25]  Compendium of R' Chajes, P 489  (published by Divrei Chachamim, 1958).
[26] R Baruch HaLevi Epstein 1860-1941, a bookkeeper by profession, and author of the Torah Temimah commentary to the Torah and Five Megilot.
[27] Torah Temimah on Shemot 21,35.
[28] 1874-1950.A leading rabbi of the island of Djerba in Tunisia. In 1943 the Nazis came to Tunisia, and demanded that Rabbi Moshe collect 50 kilos of gold in three and a half hours and hand it over to them; otherwise they would bomb the Jewish communities of Djerba and Tunis. The next day the Allies conquered Tunisia and the Nazis were gone from Tunisia. The gold that the Jews managed to collect was not handed to the Germans. He was a great Zionist and hatched a plan to establish a League of Nations and a World Court, both of which would have their headquarters in Jerusalem.
[29] These refer to not having to return a Gentile’s lost articles and not having to return funds overpaid in monetary transactions.
[30] Iggeret 89, Mishpat Cohen 63.                
[31] Igrot ha-Raayah,89, v. 1, p. 99 (Mossad ha-Rav Kook edition, Jerusalem, 1962). 



Wednesday, 3 June 2015

051) Women, Tefillin And Cars

51) Women, Tefillin And Cars

After R Shmuel Wosner, the Belzer Rebbe and R Amnon Yitzchak have decreed that women should not drive motor cars, it is refreshing to find another rabbinic authority who adopts a very different approach with regard to women.

In Rabbi Eliezer Melamed’s Peninei Halacha, the author presents a most daring approach to women and Tefillin.

He begins by explaining that the reason why women do not wear Teffillin, is because of a fundamental principle in Jewish law – that women are exempt from positive commandments that are bound by time constraints. Tefillin falls neatly into that category because it is a positive (or ‘thou shalt’, as opposed to a ‘thou shalt not’) mitzvah, and it is limited only to weekdays (Tefillin are not worn on Shabbos, Yomtov or at night).

So far so good.

Then he goes on to explain that because of the Tefillin’s extraordinary holiness, over time, we have minimalised its usage because we are no longer as spiritual as we used to be. This is why nowadays men no longer wear Tefillin for the entire duration of the day as they used to. And this is also why women do not wear Tefillin at all (as some may have in the past). Thus across the board, both men and women have been marginalised to a degree from its performance.

The wording, however, is very interesting. He never says women cannot wear Tefillin. Instead he says[1] that the custom is for women to desist from wearing them[2].

Now for the bombshell.

He continues: “If a woman asks if it would benefit her to wear Tefillin, she should be discouraged from doing so. But, if she persists, and wants to do so modestly (i.e. not make a show out of it) - it would not be correct to deny her that right. Even though many would disagree, this holds true because there does exist a basis for this expediency. And the principle is that whenever we have ‘al mah lismoch’ (i.e. a precedent or basis), we can never reject it outright.”

Wow!

He does, however, object to women abusing the privilege as a means for social protest.

Women wearing Tefillin is a very emotive issue, which will evoke all sorts of responses by people on all sides of the halachik spectrum. This is understandable and to be expected.

However, what I love about Rabbi Melamed is his unwavering commitment to the principle of Halachik precedent which he is not scared to make constant use of. He sticks steadfastly to the idea that any and all legitimate Torah views are exactly that: legitimate Torah views. And he is fearless in his reliance on them if and when a need arises.

This is why I consider him to be an honest, sensible, practical, relevant and 'Ethical Halachacist'[3]. 












[1] Quoting the Magen Avraham and the Aruch HaShulchan.
[2] Here are some of the views for and against:
·      The Mishna in Berachot 20a says that women are Patur (exempt) from Tefillin, but it does not address the issue of a woman who may want to wear them (like the case of women who may want to observe other time bound mitzvos like Lulav and Shofar, which they may do).
·       A Braita in Eruvin 96a, records how Shaul’s daughter Michal, used to wear Tefillin, and the sages did not oppose it. (Tosafot, however says they did oppose it, because of ‘guf naki’. The challenge to this is the fact that the reason given is ‘zeman grama’ not ‘guf naki’. Even those who are lenient, agree that Tefillin should never be worn during menstruation, and that is why the directive is for her to wear Tefillin modestly and privately.)
·      Some say that Michal knew she possessed a reincarnated male soul.
·      There is much discussion as to the truth behind the common perception that Rashi’s daughters wore Tefillin.
·      The Ramo writes that the reason women should not wear Tefillin is because they would not be sufficiently well versed in laws that generally do not apply to them.
·      The Shulchan Aruch YD 38,3, says clearly that women should not wear Tefillin, even if they want to.
·      The Kabbalah also bring reasons to discourage women from wearing Tefillin.
·      There is evidence that some women during the early and latter generations did wear Tefillin, such as the wife of R Chaim ben Attar.
·      The Orchot Chaim and the Olat Tamid say that if a woman persists, she may wear Tefillin.
·      The Aruch HaShulchan writes that if a woman is known to be righteous she may wear Tefillin.


[3] See post 50.

Sunday, 31 May 2015

UPDATE TO KOTZK BLOG 42 "WHAT THEY FORGOT TO TELL US"

THE GLORIOUS POOR

The following is an extract from a recent pamphlet distributed by Kupat Haír, a charity endorsed by many contemporary Gedolim: "..when you give a poor man money - you feel great, but....With Kupat Ha'ir you get to be part of feeding tens of thousands of poor people, each a evyon mehudar...We're not talking about people who need a bit of assistance...we are referring to twenty-five thousand people who truly lack bread to eat." 
What amazes me is that notwithstanding what is being described here as a humanitarian disaster and tragedy by any standards, if you were to offer these 25 000 people the possibility to work - how many of them would accept your offer? Any way, their leaders forbid secular studies which to a large extent precludes the possibility of ever being able to earn a living. Is it really such a mitzvah to help people who refuse an opportunity to better their lives and instead opt for charity in the first instance?
And the crowning insult to humanity is calling these poor people 'mehudarim' (glorified).

Counter this attitude with someone like Rabbi Soloveitchik who rejects views held by religious thinkers who see no religious significance in participation in secular society. He was fascinated by space exploration, established Yeshiva University and encouraged religious people to get degrees and professions. He said; "I hardly believe that any responsible man of faith, who is interested in the destiny of his community and wants to see it thriving and vibrant, would recommend the philosophy of contemptus saeculi (contempt for the secular)."

Rabbi Soloveitchik tells us that the concern should rather be for secular man, not secular knowledge.
He also warns us not to confuse religious faith for religious culture.


WOMEN DRIVERS

It now seems as if modern day Belzer Chassidim have inadvertently aligned themselves with Saudi Arabian ideology, which imposes a driving ban on women. The fifth and present Belzer Rebbe, Rabbi Yissachar Dov Rokeach, has thrown his weight behind a directive to expel school children in London’s Stamford Hill, if their mothers drive them to school. This is because in his view, women should not be allowed to drive, as this transgresses the Torah laws of Tzniut (modesty). The Belzer dynasty is no small insignificant sect. They number among the larger and more powerful of international Chassidic movements, with strong communities in the West, including Great Britain, Canada and America.[1]

In 2013, Rabbi Amnon Yitzchak, a leading Sefardi Hareidi, cited HaGaon HaRav Shmuel Halevi Wosner (considered by many to have been the Posek HaDor or leading Halachik authority of the generation), who also said that it was forbidden for women to drive. This, said Rabbi Yitzchak was forbidden by Rabbi Wosner, “Betachlit HaIssur” (as an absolute and serious prohibition). He further said that “this is halacha because it is not tzniut for a woman to be a driver”.[2]

This is yet another example of the reform and radicalization of Judaism slowly moving across the globe, and an utter misrepresentation of genuine Halacha.


THE iPHONE

Rabbi Yitzchak Yosef, the Sefardic Chief Rabbi of Israel, said; “If there is a student with an iPhone, then he needs to be kicked out of the yeshiva...” He went on to say that he had in fact told a student who had such a device, to bring a bowl of water to class and “...I put it inside, it bubbled and was gone.”  He further claimed that he did not have to pay damages to the student who, he suggested, could go to the Beth Din if he had a problem with the decision.

This, however is not a new innovation of the Chief Rabbi. Even the illustrious scholar Rabbi Chaim Kanievsky said; “It is forbidden to be in possession (of an iPhone) and one must burn it.”
Rabbi Kanievsky was asked by a businessman if he could use such a phone for his urgent business, and he replied; “It is forbidden to own one, and one is obligated to burn it. It cannot be sold to a non-Jew under the prohibition of selling weapons to a gentile.” [3]






[1] See THE TIMES OF ISREAL May 29 2015
[2] See theyeshivaworld.com Nov 13 2013
[3] See Times of Israel Feb 1 2015

Sunday, 29 March 2015

050) The Ethical Halachist

Jewish Law, or Halacha, is often presented as a dry and matter-of-fact compilation of Torah related jurisprudence. Not having been raised in religious Zionist circles where the writings of Rabbi Eliezer Melamed were studied, I was nevertheless so delighted to have discovered his teachings. He writes and expounds Halacha, clearly, concisely and relevantly, making sure to always place a strong emphasis on morality and ethics.


   
                                                  Rabbi Eliezer Melamed, author of the Peninei Halacha series.

His iconic work, ‘Peninei Halacha’, means Pearls of Law. And I think I have discovered some of these pearls. Let me cite a few examples to give you some idea of what I mean:

1)      With regard to the laws of re-heating liquids on Shabbos, the Ashkenazim and Yemenites differ fundamentally as to its permissiblity.[1] So what happens when an Ashkenazi goes to visit a Yemenite on Shabbos, may he partake of his host’s food?
Now, I did a little experiment. I asked a number of my colleagues what they would say if asked the same question. They all said the answer was no. I also thought the answer would be no. But the Peninei Halacha says: “When an Ashkenazi visits a Yemenite on Shabbos, he may partake of the food because the host is following his own practice and his Halacha. Every single Jew may Lechatchila (in the first instance) eat that food (even though it may not be their practice to do so in their own homes).”

2)      In reply to a question about custom, Rabbi Melamed writes: “I was once a guest at a family whose custom is to wash their hands before Kiddush, and they asked me if I wanted them to alter their custom in my honor. I answered them ‘quite the opposite’.”[2] Custom is something we all take very seriously, but he was prepared to forgo his, in deference to that of his hosts. I wonder how often this scenario of respect plays out in the real world?

3)      It is more important to pray with a Minyan than to attend a Bris Mila (circumcision). However, Rabbi Melamed adds that if the family of the child would get upset by his non attendance, he may pray at home, miss the Minyan and attend the Bris.[3] Here again, human feelings were factored into his equation. 

4)      Regarding the question of whether or not a boy under BarMitzva can be counted towards a Minyan, the Peninei Halacha explains that it is actually a debate among the Amoraim (the rabbis of the Gemora period). Most views say the answer is no. However, after going through various sources, he says that (because the concept of a Minyan is only DeRabbanan – of rabbinical origin) where a community experiences difficulty with their numbers for a Minyan, they may rely on minority opinions and indeed include a young child.[4]  A functioning minyan is often a highly emotive issue, especially in dwindling communities. Once more, his empathy (not just his knowledge), clearly informed his decision.

5)      When it come to the custom of choosing a community in which to belong, he writes; “It would be good to move to a place where there is a synagogue with your minhag (custom). This is on the condition, however, that the community acts with a Torah attitude towards derech eretz, namely, they have a positive attitude towards earning a living and secular studies, or at the very least, do not object to it, as some Hareidim mistakenly do. This is because the right attitude towards work and secular studies is far more important and fundamental than the nusach (rite) of prayer.”[5]

6)      Concerning the very controversial debate in Israeli media as to whether civil, as opposed to religious marriages should be adopted by the state, Rabbi Melamed writes; “While we believe that the State of Israel must have a Jewish character, we also do not wish to cause grief to anyone. Nor do we claim the authority to interfere with one’s personal life and tell him who to live with, or how[6]. It should be established that any two people are entitled to sign a domestic partnership agreement that grants them all privileges derived from a shared life, like a family.”[7]

7)      This is what he says about conversions; “How many laws must a convert be taught before he is asked if he is ready to accept upon himself the commandments of the Torah?...It is clear to all that there is no need to teach him the entire Torah. It is sufficient to teach him some of its foundations, and if he accepts them, it is already possible to convert him. This is what the Shulchan Aruch says; ‘He is taught some of the minor commandments and some of the major commandments. But we do not overburden him and we are not overly strict with him.’[8]  He need not be taught all the fine details and stringencies...The reason for this is that even if he is sincere, if he is suddenly confronted with all these stringencies, he will recoil and change his mind about converting.”[9]

8)      When asked about his view concerning some the contemporary Gedolim (Torah leaders), he said; “Torah greatness necessitates an all-embracing, fully accountable handling of serious issues facing the generation, including: the attitude towards Am Yisrael in all its diversity and various levels – both religious and non-religious...the attitude towards science and work, and contemporary social and economic questions...The simple answer is; I don’t consider them Gedolei haTorah.”[10]

9)      Rabbi Melamed also has a strong position on the thorny issue of segregating men and women on busses[11]. He believes that ‘Mehadrin’ busses undermine family structures, as men are unable to sit with their wives and daughters, and mothers are unable to sit with their sons. “There are very clear boundaries in halacha distinguishing between what is required and what is optional. When you try to obligate people to follow a custom that is laudatory but not actual halacha, you destroy the very foundations of Torah and halacha...It is important not to add additional stringencies when it come to matters of tznius (modesty).”[12]

10)   He is also very in favour of Christians who support Israel. He says; “We must battle missionaries, not moral Christians who respect our religion and support us. These are about 70 million citizens of the largest superpower in the world...Their moral stature is higher and more exulted that that of the Persian King Cyrus who assisted the return to Zion...American Evangelists are the most important and meaningful group supporting Israel nowadays.”[13]                                                                         
                                                                                                                                                  

      It is so refreshing and exciting to follow the teachings of a leading rabbi who carries with him a general ethos of sensibility and social responsibility. This philosophy seems to flow through all his writings, and serves as a constant practical reminder to his students and readers, of the ethical imperative required of a Torah Jew. Far from being insular, he constantly reminds us that it is possible to function in, influence and contribute to, the society around us, without having to compromise our commitment to Torah. Although not without opposition, his work is fast becoming a major force to be reckoned with in the Halachik sphere today.
                                                                          
      It seems as if Rabbi Melamed is finally putting the ‘Jew’ back into jurisprudence.
        
      The Kotzker Rebbe said that there is no mitzvah to just become a scholar, amassing huge amounts of knowledge, if it is not directed to practical good. He said the sole purpose of studying Torah was to affect good[14].

His best friend, the Vurka Rebbe said that the most important thing he learned from the Kotzker, was that “...to get to the inner garment, one first has to remove the outer garment”[15]. This means that before one overly concerns oneself with the ‘inner garment’ - the soul, and the theology that goes with it -  one has to work with the ‘outer garment’ – the social behaviour, which is the only real aspect of the religious persona that the rest of the world actually sees.        




[1] Ashkenazim, following the Ramo, do not permit re-heating a liquid (say soup), that has cooled down. Yemenites, however, following the Rambam, Rashba and Ran, maintain that it is permissible.
[2] How Binding is Minhag? By R Eliezer Melamed.
[3] Peninei Halacha, HaMinyan 5.
[4] Peninei Halacha, HaMinyan 6, note 7.
[5] How Binding is Minhag? By R Eliezer Melamed.
[6] In a similar vein consider the Bostoner Rebbe’s recent statement about being “afraid of a Halachik state” should the religious parties get a majority; “...I am afraid of the day we have 61 MKs because I don’t know how you can run a state with the responsibilities of keeping Torah...in the modern world I don’t know how you can do that...Thank G-d no one comes to ask me these types of questions.” Quoted in nrg.co.il 3/3/2015.
[7] R, Melamed quoted in The Jewish Week 06/242014. He does, however, insist on the caveat that not all domestic partnerships are called ‘marriage’.
[8] Yoreh Deah 268;2
[9] How Much Must the Convert Learn Before Conversion? R Eliezer Melamed.
[10] R. Melamed quoted in Israel National News August 13 2013.
[11] R. Melamed does, however, encourage separate seating at religious gatherings such as wedding etc.
[12] R. Melamed quoted in Vos Iz Neias, December 28 2011.
[13]R. Melamed quoted in Breaking Israel News June 29 2014.
[14] Amud HaEmet p 107, par 4. ‘Study it well (good)’ (Yeshayahu 1,17), means study it – not to be a scholar- but (lehaytiv) in order to do good. ‘Bechol haTorah kulo, lo matzanu shum mitzvah liheyot lamdan...vekavanato la’asot  et hatov ’
[15] Amud HaEmet p 191, par 7. The Gemora also speaks of ‘Tocho Keboro’, where the ideal state is for the ‘inside’ to reflect the ‘outside’. Not the other way around. So that, ideally the first thing to change in any religious encounter should be the ‘outside’. 

Thursday, 12 February 2015

049) Writing Women Out Of Judaism

When 44 world leaders marched in Paris after the Charlie Hebdo massacre, an ultra-Orthodox newspaper, HaMevasser, reported on the event. The problem was that there were now only 40 leaders because 4 had been photoshopped out of the picture. Why? -Because they were women.[1]

Spot the difference between the first picture as seen through the real lens of a camera, and the second picture, as depicted in HaMevasser:

 
                                                    
             A similar thing happened to Hilary Clinton who was also removed from a photograph taken during the Bin Laden mission, by an American Chassidic newspaper, Der Zeitung:  


Ironically in all these pictures the women were dressed very modestly with coats and jackets, but still, it seems as if the editors were less concerned with Geneivas Da’as (deceit), and more concerned with, totally obliterating women from the public arena.[2]

In a brilliantly jarring article, Shoshana Jaskoll writes:

“Do I care if an insular community, in their own place and tiny publications omit women? Yes I do; but I would not be writing about it if it remained within said small community. Instead it is spreading...
In some communities, women’s names are not printed. Not in publications and not in announcements such as wedding invitations.
A baby formula even stopped printing an outline of a mother holding her baby.
(...words like “breast cancer” are not used in Charedi society...Because of this extreme take on modesty, women are less aware, get fewer mammograms...The rate of death from breast cancer is estimated at 30 percent higher among Charedi women...Excluding women from health pamphlets, both as doctors and as patients, can only exacerbate this phenomenon.)
A (recent) book depicts a Shabbat table – completely female free. The entire book dedicated to the Shabbat, a day of family and Torah, is devoid of even one girl or woman. Where is Ima??
My preteen daughters were told to go to the back of the bus on their way home from school. Extremism seeps outward.
Beyond the damage it does to boys. Beyond the damage it does to girls. Beyond the damage it does to a healthy society where respect, interaction and balance between genders should be the norm. Beyond all of this – it is a falsehood...it is a LIE.”[3]

On the shelves of a shop featured below, the female has been covered over with a piece of paper:



Remember the iconic picture below? This is how the ultra-Orthodox weekly Bakehila (re)printed the photo, blurring out the face of the Jewish women:

Amazingly, we are quick to say ‘yemach shemam’ (may their memory be blotted out) when we speak of the Nazis. But now we print Nazis and blot out Jewish women. [4]

The great strength of the Kotzker Rebbe was his fearless ability to always stand for truth. He spoke out against so many things he believed to be wrong with the  Judaism of his day. I could never, even in my wildest moments of religious fervour, ever believe that this position on women is truthful Judaism. Keeping quiet and not registering opposition, allows the deception to perpetuate itself. Were that to happen, we would have written in new innovations that are nothing other than reforms... and have written women completely out of Judaism.

The Kotzker Rebbe wrote extensively against religious fanaticism, which was rapidly becoming prevalent in the mid 1800’s.[5] (He passed away in 1859). He said; “There will come a time when those who dress in white garb (i.e. the extremists), will need all the help they can get, to prevent them from turning to a distortion of Judaism”.[6]




[1] The four women were German Chancellor Angela Merkel, Paris Mayor Anne Hidalgo, EU foreign affairs and security chief Frederica Mogherini, and Danish Prime Minister Helle Thorning-Schmidt (who was cropped and only her hand remains in the altered photograph).
[2]It needs to be pointed out that not all Chareidim buy into this new trend of writing women out of Judaism. Unfortunately the term ‘Chareidi’ is very misleading.  I wish we would come up with another designation for the extreme ultra-Orthodox, to differentiate between them and the centralists. See a very balanced article; “Who are THE Chareidim?” by Ronit Peskin, Times of Israel May 22, 2013. Nevertheless, there does seem to be a gradual leaning towards the right, with many centralists tacitly endorsing some of the sentiments of their far-right counterparts.
[3] See full article; ‘Vanishing Women’, Times of Israel January 20, 2015.
[4] See Kotzk Blogs 42 “What They Forget To Tell Us”, for more examples of censorship by the ultra-Orthodox.
[5] See Kotzk Blogs 41 “The Reforms Of The Ultra-Orthodox”, for a short history of the rise of the ultra-Orthodox.
[6] Amud HaEmet p 187, par 3.